Where is the Value in Security?
You know, the industry has changed so much in 23 years.
So it's no longer adequate to leave your old analog premise-based security system in place.
You have to think about investing to evolve that technology.
It's a great business and it saves lives, but goodness, there's been so much
investment there and so much consolidation.
When they were trading at one to two times revenue, they're trading at four to five times
revenue today. That's a transformational change in their business model, and it's a billion-dollar
plus valuation today. SaaS is kind of changing things for integrators and their service offering.
It seems like there's been a real shift towards SaaS as an important component of manufacturing
businesses. So it's surprising to me that that opportunity is being left off the table.
Good morning and welcome to Coffee Break with Jake.
Thank you all so much for being here.
For those of you that may be new to the call, we host Coffee Break with Jake every Friday at 11 a.m. Eastern.
I'm Jake, and I'm glad to be here.
guys. I want to let you know, I selfishly host this call every Friday because the most important
things I know I've learned from other people. And so I'm very appreciative of the awesome guests
that we have on here that share their expertise. I do want to let you know that all of these
episodes are edited and published on all the major podcast platforms as Coffee Break with Jake. So be
sure to subscribe and listen at your convenience. Today, I'm especially excited to be joined by
John Mack with Raymond James. John, thank you so much for being here. I think most of the folks in
the call know exactly who you are, but for the sake of those on the call that may be less familiar,
would you tell us a little bit about yourself and your background in the security industry?
Sure. First role in the industry was many, many years ago at Westec Security in the early 90s,
where I was head of sales for Westec, was ultimately bought by SecurAmerica and sold to ADT.
I then was part of a team that bought Protection One from the utility in Oregon.
We built up Protection One to be the number two player in the security industry in the mid-late 90s,
took it public, and I ran it as a public company for a period of time.
Sold that to a utility.
I founded my own investment banking business in the security industry, urged that with Imperial Capital, and ultimately spent many years in the 2000s building Imperial Capital to be one of the leading investment banks doing work in the security industry.
And then more recently, I took my team doing security work at Imperial and went over to Raymond James, larger platform, more resources to work with Albert Chatingok.
We had been competitors for years, but friendly competitors.
We've become good friends.
And so joining up with him has been a wonderful evolution in my career and the opportunity to really build a leading franchise doing investment banking work in the security industry.
So there it is in about 30 seconds.
John, every year you host the Security Investor Conference in New York.
I had the opportunity to attend at least once.
I don't know if it's been more than once, but I really enjoyed attending and some of the presentations.
Obviously, the security industry has evolved since you started that.
And can you tell me, when did the Security Investor Conference start?
How many years has that been running?
This year will be the 23rd year of the Security Investor Conference.
And I'm proud to say that the founding idea behind it was to try and attract more investors to understand what was happening in the physical security industry,
because nobody really understood it as a category for investors.
And I had to do some pretty aggressive work to get investors convinced to come to the conference in the early days.
And I'm happy to say that 22, 23 years later, we now have to limit attendance from investors
because the category is so sought after that we've got more than we can handle for interest, which is great.
And I think, you know, anybody in the industry would be aware of the increased investor interest in the category.
And I'll take a small portion of credit for creating more visibility for the industry over the last 20 years through that conference.
You know, the industry has changed so much in 23 years.
If I was to go to the conference in 2005 versus today, what would look the most different?
Well, I'd say just the breadth of the companies. We now track, we identify 16 categories that we sort of put in our research reports and track. But every year that we go to put those categories together, we struggle because we could easily have 24, 32, 48.
Because there's so many different subcategories or different components of what's happening in the physical security world. And we all know that we're integrating those solutions for customers, but there are a lot of subcomponents of technology that encompass the broader physical security world.
So I'd say one meaningful dimension is just the breadth of different kinds of companies and categories within physical security.
And the other dimension would just be size.
You know, there was only a handful of bigger players, you know, Honeywell prominently amongst them.
But, you know, if we look around today, there's many, many billion dollar plus players in the category.
There's many several hundred million dollar players in the category.
So I'd say that the breadth of the category with all the different technologies and the size of some of the players in the category and, of course, probably the total number.
You mentioned you have to limit you have to limit the folks coming in now.
Obviously, there's so much interest in the security industry.
What do you think what do you think is attracting strategic and private equity capital?
You know, over the years, over multiple economic cycles, why is physical security so attractive?
It obviously ultimately has to do with the fundamental drivers of growth and the size of the market and things like that, because investors aren't going to be interested in categories where there isn't fundamental growth.
There isn't a decent sized market. There isn't an opportunity to invest with growth.
And so, you know, there's several different dimensions to the market that are creating this wonderful opportunity for our industry today.
The first and foremost is what I tend to refer to frequently as sort of a generation of change out in technology.
We all know that we're moving from older analog systems to digital.
That's been going on for a long time.
We're moving from older premise-based server software systems to cloud-based SaaS business models, but still hardware-enabled business models.
And now, of course, we're figuring out how to have agentic AI applications within our physical security platforms. And all of that change out in technology is part of what's fueling the market today.
And the companies are looking at the fact that they've got aging out technology. And then that the second sort of big idea is that people are much more concerned about security as an issue and the idea that physical security ultimately impacts cybersecurity as well.
And so this whole thematic focus on security means that there is an imperative to invest in that generational change out of technology.
It's no longer adequate. And it's all the way up to the board level where people are talking about this.
So it's no longer adequate to leave your old analog premise based security system in place.
You have to think about investing to all that technology.
And then the other big trend that we've seen is the multifaceted use case for all that security technology. It used to be years ago, you were just investing in security technology to mitigate the potential for crime or theft. And today, that technology is being used for all kinds of other applications that have operational benefits within your business, right?
We all know that cameras in particular can be used to do everything from inventory to marketing tracking to safety and a whole host of related kinds of activities.
And so that multifaceted use case means that that physical security investment is a much higher priority for the CFO when they're looking at CapEx opportunities across the business.
If you can make an investment, improve security, but also get a bunch of operational benefits, you're going to improve your business at the same time.
It's much easier to justify making that investment.
And so those are those are hands full.
there's a whole host of different, if you go industry by industry, there's a host of different
initiatives. If you look at critical infrastructure spending, that's a big category of spending that's
happening in this sector. So there's a lot of dimensions on which there is growth in the
industry and the fundamental changes in the business model, I think, make the industry more
profitable and so all of those things together uh constitute uh you know the opportunity and the
size of that market uh just to sort of hit on the last point i was making the size of that market
when you add all of that up across you know access control identity video surveillance and
intrusion and the gentic models uh that that applied all of that uh you end up with you know
hundreds of billions of dollars of of tam for our sector and that creates a really attractive
an investment opportunity. So, you know, you mentioned that we could kind of unpack things
depending on kind of the subcategories. And I'd like to do a little bit of that today with you.
You know, specifically, I want to start with the integrator side of things. As investors are
looking at integrators, what do you think is genuinely valuable from an investor perspective
in an integrator versus something that maybe traditional security integrators are laser
focused on right now, but maybe missing the bigger opportunity. Where do these strategic
investors really see the most value in integrators today? Integrators are going to continue to play
an important role in the market from here to some unforeseeable time in the future. You're not going
to be able to disintermediate the need to install this physical security infrastructure.
And so one of the interesting reasons why our industry is getting a lot more attention
today than five years ago even is that people are moving to categories where AI can enhance
the business model, but it's not going to disintermediate it.
So we've all heard of the SaaSpocalypse, which, by the way, I think was substantially
overblown.
And but it used to be the case that we would have investors coming to us and not infrequently saying, you know, you guys are the guys that have all that hardware in your business model.
And we really want to look at investment opportunities that have more software, SaaS only.
And we said, no, no, you're missing the point here.
That hardware that we're installing frequently, we're making a good gross margin on that.
And that's kind of the anchor.
And then we have these service SaaS enabled models sitting on top of that hardware that's critical to the solution.
And they're like, yeah, yeah, yeah.
We just want to talk about software.
A lot of those guys are coming back to us to saying, wait a minute, aren't you those guys with the hardware that creates this structure?
And so we truly have a much richer conversation with people who now appreciate that hardware enabled model.
and that's certainly driving some of the current interest.
And I say all that as a backdrop to saying,
what's the critical linchpin in deploying those solutions?
You have to have an integrator who can put in
a sophisticated set of hardware
that is part of that solution.
Video surveillance, access control readers,
locks of hardware, intrusion devices, et cetera, et cetera.
And so I think that solution is more important.
And I think that the more sophisticated deployments, which are increasingly a big part of the industry,
I mean many of the bigger players in our industry are doing an awful lot of work in the data center space today as I think everybody realizes But yeah obviously that more sophisticated work today And so you know there a real premium being placed on the value of that
and the people are paying good margins for that kind of deployment work.
If I'm a security integration company, maybe one of the folks listening in on the call today,
and I have absolutely no intention of selling my integration business,
what can I still learn from the way that investors are valuing my business today?
The valuation parameters in many respects just haven't changed over time.
There's just more of a focus on the value of companies in this industry because of the opportunity based on what I just described.
But when people look at businesses, they care about things like the free cash flow conversion.
So it's one thing to talk about EBITDA, but if you're capitalizing a lot of expense, you may not have as much free cash flow.
So people have always cared about cash flow.
And then you have fundamental organic growth focus.
People care about business models where you're able to fundamentally grow the business organically.
I think some focus on good organic growth has been lost in the incredible focus on M&A in the sector.
And I think that's overblown and people should pay more attention to organic growth.
We're going to be announcing a transaction security integration space here shortly, a pretty sizable deal.
It was a company that was growing incredibly well organically, and they got a really good valuation because of that.
So organic growth is a really important part of that.
Your gross margins.
And then, of course, recurring revenue is important because typically recurring revenue in our industry, whether it's monitoring or service contracts or otherwise, is frequently going to be higher margins.
So if you've got a meaningful component of your business where you've managed to sell recurring services at higher gross margins, that's consistently inside your business model, that's going to impact value.
So, you know, the attractiveness of the end markets are you a leading player doing work regionally in important end markets, utilities and infrastructure and health care, hospitals, pharmaceutical.
I can name a whole bunch of verticals that are attractive.
Are you disproportionately succeeding in those verticals?
So kind of rambling a little bit on you here, but you certainly get a sense.
And all of those things I just described, I could have said the same thing 20 years ago.
So the fundamentals of valuation really haven't changed.
People are just recognizing that there's more opportunity to realize those outcomes in the market today.
You know, my conversations with operators of wholesale monitoring centers, technology changes and shifts towards video monitoring are really changing the role of the monitoring center today.
Do you think that monitoring is still one of the most attractive models in the security industry today?
Yeah, absolutely.
We at Raymond James, I was doing it in Imperial and we sort of consolidated our efforts.
We've probably easily been the leading bank doing investment bank doing transactions in the remote video sector, video honoring sector.
We just closed the ProVigil deal.
We did NetWatch a little while ago, got a large transaction coming in Europe.
So we've been quite active in this category.
We've seen it for quite some time as a really active opportunity for growth and building successful businesses.
And lo and behold, that's been the case. And I think, you know, thematically, one of the things that remote video is doing that people tend to lose a little bit of sight of in the context of just talking about monitoring is this is perimeter protection.
And I think there is thematically a much bigger focus on why perimeter security makes sense. If you're putting all kinds of technology to protect your building, but it's inside the building, missing the point that a meaningful part of the threat to the facility, to the employees and the operation is the perimeter.
increasingly there's an opportunity for you know some level of autonomous monitoring because we
all know that ai is now able to discern a meaningful part of what would have 10 years ago
been strictly human operator based uh monitoring activity and so we're finding a really interesting
continuum between what needs to be operator based and really what's happening is the ai is able to
triage a lot of what might have been false alarm activity such that operators are now looking at
genuine real event issues that need intervention from a human operator. So there's going to
continue to be a very interesting element to the remote video monitoring sector with the use of
AI and where humans versus autonomous monitoring is going to be the case.
Do you think that it changes the margins for those monitoring centers? We've seen so much pricing pressure on wholesale monitoring centers. I mean, I joke that if I die and go to hell, I'll be a Central Station monitoring sales rep one day because it's so competitive. But how do you think that the changes in kind of those services that they're providing, what's going to be the impact on monitoring centers in terms of how much revenue they're going to be able to collect?
Yeah, you've focused the question on wholesale monitoring centers, and I'm sort of answering the question.
The last question I answered was much more about just the fundamental proposition for remote video monitoring to be end user, right?
Sure.
That is a monitoring dealer who owns and operates their own center selling, or it's a dealer who's using third-party monitoring.
I think the same logic I was applying makes sense.
I think there's going to continue to be a very good opportunity for wholesale.
I think there's going to be consolidation in the space for kind of obvious reasons.
But there's a big group of integrators in the market today who don't have monitoring centers and they're not going to want to build them.
So if they want to bring that solution to their customer and they have really good opportunities for perimeter security that involve video monitoring,
I think they're going to be looking for a partner in a really good remote video monitoring wholesale provider to do that.
Now, a meaningful percentage of the remote, the wholesale monitoring community hasn't really fully embraced remote video.
So we also have to talk about the fact that you've got an old school, the regular way alarm monitoring wholesale industry.
And then you've got some newer players that have dedicated themselves to this and you've got a hybrid, you know, sort of affiliated and rapid and cops are doing remote video to varying degrees.
But I think, you know, the ability to specialize and execute well on that model is going to be a nice opportunity for players who want to focus on that category from the wholesale and retail perspective.
You know, John, as much as SaaS is kind of changing things for integrators and their service offering, it seems like there's been a real shift towards SaaS as an important component of manufacturing businesses.
You know, I saw NAPCO's latest quarterly report that recurring revenue, that their recurring revenue is a meaningful portion of their revenue today and at a 90 percent gross margin.
How do you think investors are looking at manufacturers? Are they more focused on manufacturers that have a cohesive software platform, or are they still interested in manufacturers that are just making widgets?
Well, there's no question investors care about that higher margin recurring revenue model. That's pretty simple, right? And easy to understand. And you could see the transformation that NAPCO created for themselves. I actually don't think it's the greatest example, but I'll finish the point by saying NAPCO, you know, 10 plus years ago was much more of a manufacturer of hardware and gross margins were traditional and they were trading at one to two times revenue.
They're trading at four to five times revenue today. That's a transformational change in their business model. And it's a billion dollar plus valuation today based on on building that recurring revenue. And it's very easy to see that the reason that they're trading at a higher rate is because of that recurring revenue.
The reason I don't say it's the greatest example is because most of that revenue is for their connectivity solution for fire panels.
And I think true SaaS solutions, something like what Brivo, EagleEye, or OpenEye at Alarm.com or many of the other examples in the marketplace of real SaaS solutions is, I think, the bigger, longer term evolution of what's happening in the manufacturing side of the business.
and our industry is very late to the game on that changeover,
and we're still late to the game.
If you look at most enterprises,
almost all their software solutions are cloud.
They're using cloud for CRM.
They're using cloud for enterprise.
They're using cloud for HR.
You know, all the platforms they're using,
NetSuite and Salesforce, et cetera.
And yet when you get to physical security,
somehow we've still got servers sitting in closets
and we're doing something different
the way we deploy. So I think we're going to see an accelerated move to that model.
And that'll be another basis for integrators to differentiate themselves as being able to embrace
that changeover. And we're seeing some, you know, movements in that direction.
They're taking advantage because the reason people weren't doing that a few years ago
was the huge install base. And so how could you convince your client to change out all their
existing hardware to put in a cloud-based system? Well, the obvious answer is to go with a hybrid
solution. So people like Acre and others built hybrid models where they've got an appliance
that goes into that system and moves everything to the cloud so that you could start the evolution
towards a cloud SaaS model, but you're still using that existing installed base infrastructure
to do that. So I think we're getting smarter about the evolution that needs to take place
to enable cloud SaaS models for our business. You know, it's been interesting to watch,
just kind of in contrast to the idea that end users might be hesitant to rip and replace
existing infrastructure with cloud-based systems. We've seen Verkada has been very successful at
at exactly that. Do you think that the long-term play is a, I don't have a better term for this,
and forgive me, but it's been referred to as the hostage as a service model that
not only is this cloud-based, but if you stop paying for your cloud services, you don't have
any useful hardware anymore. Do you think that manufacturers are going to move more and more
towards that model? Or do you think a hybrid approach of layering software on top of usable
hardware makes sense? I think it'll be both. I think where the value proposition that somebody
selling a new system is making the investment in the hardware on behalf of the customer,
such that the customer is just making an operating expense investment to change out all that
infrastructure. I think the company is rightfully saying, hey, we're taking a fairly significant
an investment risk to move you to this model. And yes, we need a return over many years to justify
that evolution. And then there'll be a different model where it's a hybrid, like I just described.
You're going to keep most of your infrastructure. You don't have to make a big investment in
hardware. In that case, it can be a different model where there is a SaaS recurring revenue
component, but it's not as big because you're using your existing hardware and infrastructure.
And so, you know, I think it's going to be somewhere in between. But I think hostage as a service is a very pejorative way to reference the idea that the manufacturer and the integrator together are partnering to provide, in the case of Verkada, it's integrated.
But in most cases, it's going to be a hardware. It's going to be a manufacturing integrator that between them are going to make the investment effectively in the hardware that's being put in the system.
And they need a return on that. Maybe less sexy than, you know, some of this cool stuff that we're doing with security and business intelligence and video monitoring, fire and life safety.
man, it's a boring, it's awesome and it's great. It's a great business and it saves lives,
but goodness, there has been so much investment there and so much consolidation. Why do you think
FIRE has attracted so much investor interest Yeah no if you were to identify a trend that both Alper and I would be the most stunned by the absolute growth in interest in fire life safety and the valuations being paid for companies in that category would certainly be one of those trends that been more surprising than others
and I think it has to do
you know you can still go back to the same
generational change out in technology
because if security integration
was slow to change out their old infrastructure
fire was even slower right
so you now have
you know the big part of the bubble
for changing out that older
analog technology
in these building systems for fire
life safety that has to be integrated
within many cases
you know newer technology for running
buildings so you just cannot
The building manager cannot tolerate the idea of an antiquated fire system while they're upgrading everything else to a new smart building platform.
So the demand drivers around this generational change are pretty easy to identify.
And then I think investors really tend to like industries where there's regulatory driven demand for the service.
And so we clearly have a very significant regulatory demand.
And because of, you know, concerns around issues that have happened, you know, maybe even a more rigorous regulatory demand for the proper fire life safety protocols with these systems.
And so I think it's a combination of this regulatory driven demand coupled with the same generational change out in technology that's driving it.
Historically, the reason why people didn't like the category was because there wasn't as much retrofit business, right? The business was much more driven by new systems and new systems were driven by new construction.
So 20 years ago, when you looked at the fire life safety market, you know, your average company had 40, 50 percent of its business or more was new construction.
And you had a fairly significant exposure to the idea that if you had a turndown in the new construction market, commercial new construction, you'd have a turndown in the category, which was generally true.
So today, a very significant percentage of what a lot of fire lab safety integrators are doing is retrofit work based on the description I just talked about.
And so those two or three things together, I think, are driving what's happening there.
But man, the valuations and the interest in the category are amazing.
Do you think it'll continue?
How long do you think that's going to be a trend that we're going to see?
I think the trend for that change out in technology has many, many years, you know, I don't know, 10 plus years to play out.
And then there'll be new evolutions of the technology that allow you to continue to grow and upgrade those systems over time.
So I think there's a decent demand driver here.
It may be the board's exaggerated or accelerated right now just because there's a bigger imperative to change out those older systems.
And at some point, a majority of those systems will be changed out.
And then there's, you didn't ask the question, but I'll answer it, which is, you know, what's
going to happen with valuations as it continued to be as frothy as it is today.
And I think that too will start to come down because ultimately at the end of the day,
you know, there has to be somebody at the end of the chain that's willing to buy these
businesses at ever higher multiples.
And I think that's going to get harder and harder to do.
Several of these businesses are going to look to get public over the next couple of years, Convergint, Pi, Summit, and others.
And, you know, we'll see how they trade as public companies.
But I think at some point there's going to be an understanding there's a certain peak to where valuations can end up if you're a sizable player.
And that's going to reverberate back through the whole ecosystem relative to what you're willing to pay for a smaller company in the midst of a buildup.
So, you know, for a lot of the folks that listed in, they're security integrators and some of them are running businesses that are project oriented, profitable businesses, strong EBITDA, but maybe not as focused on RMR.
And then other companies may be primarily focused on RMR and customer retention, but less focused on, you know, strong EBITDA.
What would you say, you know, if you were talking to one of those security integrators today, where do you think their focus should be on driving the most revenue in their business?
I think if you're truly an integrator today, the model really needs to be focused on driving even today.
I think it's both harvesting your existing customer base.
Most integrators do 70, 80% of their businesses with their existing customer base if you're a more established business.
And only 20 or 30% is really new logos that are coming into your business.
So I'd say, you know, effectively focus on getting good blended gross margins for what you do.
Focus on getting contracts for recurring revenue, but not some sort of big transformational change in your model to start investing in recurring revenue.
But invariably, I think you want to keep an eye on the cloud-based business model approach.
I think increasingly you're going to find more of your customers want to do Brivo or OpenEye or the new version of Acre or even Linnell's cloud-based system, which is going to have a recurring revenue, but it's still going to have a meaningful upfront installation that's going to drive near-term profitability.
So I think you're invariably going to end up with a focus on building recurring revenue, but you're not necessarily going to have to meaningfully sacrifice EBITDA to do that.
So, you know, we've seen a shift. It used to be that the security integrator and in many cases, the security integrator still is the technology gatekeeper and the security expert and consultant recommending solutions.
But we've seen a trend towards some SaaS slash hardware manufacturers that are going direct to the end users and driving demand for their products and their platforms.
Do you think that there's the risk that integrators are reduced to skilled labor, or do you think they still have the opportunity to own that customer relationship and help make those decisions long term?
Oh, I think I'm much more bullish on the dealer model than I am vertical integration in the category.
I mean, you have to have an awfully big balance sheet to pursue the vertical integration strategy.
And, you know, the Verkada story hasn't fully played out yet.
So whether that's really going to ultimately turn into a financial success and being able to get public and get returns back to early investors in the model that hasn't been proven out yet.
And the amount of investment they've had to put into that to try and execute that model has been very, very significant, as we know.
I think the model is a partnership, and that's increasingly what we're seeing, and it's a pretty obvious partnership, particularly for larger customers.
Again, I'm using the same names just because they're people I know, but Brivo, OpenEye, Acre, et cetera.
All of these customers are spending time working on demand, driving demand within categories that matter to them and partnering with their dealers to execute on the demand that they've created.
They haven't gone to the dealer and said, look, we're going to bring you a lead. We just want you to be our subcontractor because most good integrators say, forget it, I'm not interested. And then they're not going to have the best integrator who's got the partnership with the customer who's really going to be on the front line.
So I think there is the ability for those bigger manufacturers to invest in demand generation, to go for those larger deals.
It is very much the case that the manufacturer and the dealer go pitch that together and they talk about features, capability and support together.
But the integrator ends up with a relationship and the customer is happy that they have an understanding of who the manufacturer is and probably have some level of a relationship there as well.
But that partnership model is still with the dealer integrator in the forefront.
Would you feel comfortable saying that the dealer integrator has the most influence over that customer relationship over the next decade?
Or do we see a shift towards manufacturers or software platforms having more of an influence in that relationship?
I think the way you frame the question, I just don't think really gets at the right approach to the issue when you talk about it as a partnership.
I think it's going to take, at least for larger enterprise, and I'm thinking about this more in enterprise, if you're talking about smaller, mid-sized businesses, unequivocally, it's the dealer.
That's easy.
But if we're going to talk about Fortune G1000 or 2000 or something in larger enterprise, then I think it is this partnership model that I just talked about.
I think it's going to be a balance between the two where the manufacturer is going to talk about the evolution of the product because the customer is so much more sophisticated today.
Right. You know, their customers showing up, they go to the ISC show, they go out all the same shows.
They know as much about the product as the integrator does in some cases.
And so they're asking about what's going to happen five years from now.
What are you doing with the agentic AI? What are you doing with new solutions?
And the part that the integrators there as a partner talking about, yes, as my partner manufacturer comes up with these new upgrade solutions, I'm going to be there and make sure they get deployed properly.
But that's the partnership conversation.
It isn't this binary system where you've got a manufacturer on one side and the integrator on the other.
I think if that G1000 conversation, it's very much an integrated discussion.
The decision makers change.
You mentioned early on that security is becoming not just, you know, it's not just security, but now it's becoming business intelligence and a part of, you know, their tech stack.
Do you feel that the decision makers within those organizations are going to change?
And does that impact how integrators should approach those relationships?
Yeah, and I think integrators already recognize that, that, you know, my comment would be providing any sort of a Tiffany to an integrator who's been selling, particularly, again, a larger customer.
The smaller the business, the less likely that that dynamic has changed from somebody who's got a broad responsibility for facilities and security or something.
But the higher up, you know, the bigger the organization, you very much have IT involved in that decision.
And so there is both physical security focused people.
There is IT people.
And then there's operations people.
You know, I've got a customer who's done a lot of work for Walmart over the years.
There's seven different departments that show up to discussions about how you're going to deploy video security surveillance technology inside stores.
Seven different departments, right?
So IT may still be pretty prominent.
There's ops folks.
There's sales and marketing folks.
There's, yeah, so it is a more complex dynamic, which is good for us because that's demonstrating that it's a much higher priority and it involves more categories within business.
And I would also say that the other side of it that I think we're all aware of is that increasingly the intersection of physical and cybersecurity is a really important part of that decision because a big part of what you're doing with physical security today is making sure the right people are accessing the network and accessing facilities where they should be accessing the network and that sort of thing.
And then even just the cybersecurity of the physical security infrastructure.
When you talk about the number of Internet-enabled devices inside of a building, a very meaningful percentage of those Internet-enabled devices in a building are secure physical security related today.
And so the cyber attack surface within their business, a meaningful percentage of it is physical security.
So the reason IT is at the table talking about speccing the system is not just the fundamental physical security attributes, but it's the fact that they want to make sure the cybersecurity components of that both to help defend against outside attack and design the system to have cyber hardening as a part of that.
So do you think that the trend will be that integrators that are pursuing those types of accounts, they have to have cybersecurity expertise and increasingly going to move from just physical security companies to cybersecurity companies as well?
I don think they have to be deploying cybersecurity solutions I still think there is a universe of people who are deploying cybersecurity solutions but I think they going to increasingly have to have a very sophisticated understanding of how to articulate why the infrastructure that they installing for the customer is going to be cyber hard And I think they going to have to have a point of view about things like identity
which is going to be common, increasingly common between cybersecurity and physical security. So the
conversation around identity is going to be more sophisticated and the access control environment
is going to have to have a much more sophisticated point of view about how you intersect with
that cybersecurity component in the world.
Because the same identity that you're using to get into the building is the identity you're
using to get into the network.
And increasingly, tracking where there may be issues is happening across both fiscal
and logical security identity, et cetera.
So you have to be pretty conversant in that if you're going to be talking about G1000
kind of solutions, for sure.
So, John, if you had $100 million to invest in, let me give you a few categories here,
because I want to understand your outlook for each of these.
You have $100 million to invest in integrators, monitoring centers doing remote video monitoring,
manufacturers, or software companies.
How do you allocate the $100 million?
I like all the categories.
So if you pick sort of best in class in each of those categories, it's hard to say.
you wouldn't find really attractive opportunities.
So it's hard to really talk about one versus the other.
You know, if I was looking at, you know, integrator versus remote video,
I'd probably be more inclined towards a remote video monitoring business
only because it intersects better with my background having come from the monitoring side.
But I've got plenty of examples of clients and friends who've done extraordinarily well on the integration side.
So I certainly understand why and how those investments can make sense.
And, you know, I think you're kind of raising an older business model idea when you talk about the difference between manufacturers and software.
So many of the examples into the future are going to be hardware enabled SaaS software businesses.
And so I love the businesses that are at that intersection because I think the adoption of that technology in the next five to 10 years is going to be significant.
And so being involved with companies who are doing a better job of that is going to be a big opportunity.
So that's the way I would think about that.
So you mentioned earlier that you feel fire and life safety.
The trend is maybe a little bit surprising.
What are you surprised?
What category surprises you that there's not more interest in?
That fundamentally good businesses, good category, but has not yet attracted investor interest at the level you might expect?
One that sticks out is not quite the way you framed the question, but I think it still answers the question.
And I'm surprised that we have, I don't know, three, four thousand integrators in the country and a pretty big market, as we've talked about in this call.
And yet a very small percentage of them today are selling a remote video monitoring perimeter solution.
So it's surprising to me that those guys haven't said, if I'm sitting inside the office of the decision makers and my client about a new physical security solution for their facility and the people, I should certainly be talking about perimeter.
And included in that should logically be, in many, many cases, remote video monitoring solutions.
So it's surprising to me that that opportunity is being left on the table.
and and interestingly i see more integrators who have figured out how to go after weapons detection
solutions and reselling weapons detection whether it's you know zero eyes or some sort of video or
bulb or whatever it might be and maybe it's because somehow that technology is easier for
them to understand and sell in a model similar to what they've been doing selling access control and
video in the past. But the idea of selling perimeter security remote video is, in my mind,
really an easy evolution of an integrator's business model. So that's the one that surprises
me probably the most. Yeah, that surprises me too. I think we run into this challenge that
consumer interest and demands diverge from dealer interest and demands to where, you know,
sometimes it's hard to teach old dogs new tricks is kind of an oversimplification of it. Some of
these businesses want to continue to operate their business as they have, even though there's a real
opportunity to sell video monitoring. Do you think that those integrators will come around or do you
think somebody steals their lunch? Oh, I think it'll be both, right? It's never, it's none of
these things are ever binary. So I think we're, we've already seen an evolution to where, you know,
the better integrators have started to figure out how to resell remote video and perimeter security solutions more, more significantly.
And and others haven't. And where others haven't, you know, that remote video player can can come into the solution.
And it's certainly the case that that remote video only players selling just that perimeter security solution are at risk as well,
because I'd be increasingly a more sophisticated customer would like to know that the DMS video surveillance speed for their overall business seamlessly incorporates perimeter remote video and interior video.
And so there needs to be an integration of the video management system that is the system of record for the business with whatever the remote video provider is putting in.
So there's also a dimension that the remote video provider, you know, really isn't doing anything inside the business or isn't doing the rest of the physical security system.
So there needs to be more of an integration of those two things in which direction it comes from.
You know, I think would be a function of who's really got the best vision for how to sell that solution.
We've seen GardaWorld make significant investments in remote video monitoring.
Do you think that the manned guard business fundamentally changes over the next few years and we see those companies shifting more towards remote guarding?
For sure. I mean, that's it. You know, Steve Jones was the keynote for the Security Investor Conference last year. He talked about it.
Um, Stephan Pritier has been talking about it for a long time.
It's a cure toss and others are all, you know, going down that evolutionary path.
And, and it's, uh, it's going to be a hybrid model where you're going to see guards and
video surveillance at the same time.
But we're also in a world where, uh, increasingly government just doesn't have the manpower
to, to fund what were tradition was traditional infrastructure, uh, across the world.
And so, interestingly, notwithstanding a move towards sort of video-related automation to replace guards, you still have this massive demand for guards because government just isn't doing as much and the man guarding industry is stepping in to replace many of those functions.
So, you know, police staffing is down and can't staff national parks and, you know, name it. And so the answer in many cases is private partnership models that the guard companies are stepping into. So it's a much longer topic on a different direction.
But there is pretty decent demand for the guard industry for people based side of their business.
But there's also going to be, as they increasingly sell to more sophisticated customers, it's going to be a hybrid model where they're going to talk about having guards that can deploy to action spots based on where there is identified trouble on the perimeter through technology.
Yeah, you know, it's interesting. Last week, I spoke with Brian Duffy of Per Mar Security Services, and he was kind of asked a similar question. And his take on it was interesting in that they do remote video monitoring today, but there are still some aspects of guarding where a guard is necessary, particularly when human interaction is needed, right?
when somebody needs to be able to walk up and ask a question and some things that you just can't do
with talk down through a camera. One of the things that he mentioned was that they also have guards
respond to alarms and these are actually key holders can unlock, disarm, rearm the system.
Do you think, you know, kind of the flip side of my earlier question, do you think that we start to
see traditional electronic security companies contracting with guard companies or forming
guard companies to provide that police response that's getting increasingly worse?
Wow, that's pulling on all different threads.
I don't see security integrators, if we're going to pick that category for a minute,
integrating into being guard businesses.
I think they'll partner with guard businesses.
I certainly have.
We have seen large guard companies that are that are integrators are in the remote video monitoring.
So they are doing their best to sell a complete solution.
But I still think there is there is distinction where just the same way the customer is going to go contract for cybersecurity solution separately.
They're going to contract for guard services where they're required.
But I think it is the case that the integrator who is designing and discussing what the remote video perimeter security solution should look like can kind of have a point of view about where man guarding should be part of that solution and suggest that, you know, when you're talking to your Securitas sales rep, you know, here's the way we think the optimal design of the system would work.
and here's where the guard would make sense to be deployed.
So I think there's going to be that kind of discussion,
just the same way you might have that kind of discussion
about how cybersecurity is being deployed,
but you're not going to be the cybersecurity solution provider.
Fair enough. That makes sense.
We're coming up on the hour.
And so I want to ask you,
what part of the security industry do you expect
will be much larger 10 years from now?
Well, by definition, given what we're talking about here, it's going to be this integrator community, fire life safety and security systems integration community.
The organic growth rates, when you take out the M&A related growth, the organic growth rates are still pretty healthy.
And they're probably higher than most other subcategories within the broader security space.
So if you take a multi-billion dollar category and you've got fundamental growth rates in the high single digits and in some cases even low double digits, in very early, that's going to be that category is going to be 10 years from now.
Well, I have to ask you the question I've been afraid to ask the whole time.
Having decided not to go into the family business, folks on a security integration company decided to get in the distribution business.
Did I make a terrible decision?
Should I have been in the integration business because distribution is not a good business?
Or what do you think?
I mean, ADI has just spun out.
Is distribution still a good business or no?
Distribution, you better have a really good specialty model or you better have scale.
One of those two things, and I think you're good to go.
Absent that, I think more challenging.
And obviously, with some of the ideas we've talked about, I think there's a big opportunity
on the integration side,
given the things you've heard me say,
I think that model has to embrace
some of these new ideas for the perimeter
and more SaaS-based solutions and what have you.
But I think there's a really nice opportunity there.
And distribution, you have to be a lot more careful
to make sure you're going to win
on one of the dimensions I just talked about.
All right, well, that's good.
I'm glad it wasn't a blanket.
You've made a big mistake, Jake.
John, thank you so much for being here today.
for everybody that joined in.
I want to thank you for joining Coffee Break with Jake.
Again, we host this call every Friday at 11 a.m. Eastern.
You're always welcome.
If you're one of the many integrators
that does business with us today,
please know that I appreciate
and I appreciate the opportunity to serve your business.
If you're an integrator and looking for a specialty distributor
that focuses on security
and can put your name on the products that you install,
I'd love to connect with you after the call.
but whether you do business with us or not,
you are always welcome on Coffee Break with Jake.
John, again, thank you so much for being here today.